Anyone finding they're warming to the Bears drafting Caleb?
Mar 25, 2024 22:03:05 GMT -6
JABF, shark86, and 2 more like this
Post by mightyjoeyoung on Mar 25, 2024 22:03:05 GMT -6
I don't think its a mental block - I think honestly it was bad coaching and a bad situation.
Nagy was the kind of coach who wanted to prove he was so smart, so he always tried to outscheme everyone, and his stuff was always overcomplicated to the point of stupidity. He didn't let his players play, and in the last year, the offensive line was TERRIBLE.
Then you had Luke Getsy, who decided he wanted to turn Justin Fields into Aaron Rodgers and also demands of his QBs to almost ALWAYS avoid the middle of the field, because that's what Aaron Rodgers does - seriously, look at their pass charts. Only Rodgers is a good enough QB to get away with that, and honestly, he does it so that his numbers are overinflated, for selfish reasons, which is a large reason why for all of his talent, Rodgers has only ever won one SuperBowl, and even then it was with a top defense. And on top of that, after 2 years with Getsy, Fields only had a halfway decent offensive line when it finally gelled after he came back from injury, which led to his best improvements.
Otherwise, most of the time, he ran for his life by necessity.
Now, there still are parts of Justin's game that are underdeveloped, but put him with a coach that has a team with a good offensive line and have that coach use Fields as Lamar Jackson, and watch him take off.
Having said all that - there's no waiting with Caleb Williams. He already has in spades the part of the game Fields is currently lacking, so I get why they are making the move.
1. The 2024 offense looks significantly more talented than what we have had in years here.
2. The 2024 coordinators seem much better. Shane Waldron was so good helping Geno resurrect his career... he is a veteran play-caller and I like his offense. With the talent on this particular Bears offense, Waldron should be rock solid as an OC.
3. As much as I liked Fields (and I did like him a lot) - I can't deny that Caleb Williams has a better mental processor. That can't be coached. You either have it as a QB1 or you don't. Caleb has it at an elite level. I watched his games live, and later I've watched his film until I think my eyes were about to drop out... he needs to develop and improve his game. But that mental CPU is what will help him in NFL games. I have zero worries about the stuff the "Internet People" bring up about the peripheral negatives (the off the field garbage stuff). He seems like a good guy to me. The people who's teams are not getting Caleb are doing the "Sour Grapes" thing now. They are jealous of us.
I am in the same boat as well. I do think had they built around Fields an offense similar to what Baltimore did with Jackson, Fields would be off to the races, but at the same time, I completely understand what Poles has been talking about recently - he was very open about it.
He said it wasn't about Fields vs the rookies in the draft. It was about Fields vs the rookie contract and the time that affords a team to figure things out - it was a financial decision and came down to business. He also went on about how he had to break the news to his son, who had a Fields Jersey hanging in his room.
Honestly, when you see him talk openly and honestly about it now, it really makes the people who just are overeager to trash Fields look absolutely foolish.
This wasn't an easy decision for Poles, which makes me honestly respect it all the more.