Who do you want as our QB now, Cutler or Hoyer?

I said a coin toss in another thread and I truly mean that.

Can't trade JC He's bad, turns ball over, locks onto receiver, has a bad attitude, coach killer, ect. If you bench him they are sayin pretty much he will be cut after season. Why would anyone trade for him? JC is an OK QB, nothing more. Plenty of worse QB's out there. Till the OL is fixed and an ANSWER to who is the next QB, you have to keep him.

Of course they can trade Cutler.  They would just have to be willing to take very little for him like a 6th round pick.

What you would need to compare the two would be to have Hoyer play when our OL sucks and our defense can't stop the opponents running game.

Then have Jay play when the OL is opening nice fat holes for the running game and we average around 5 YPC and give Jay 4+ seconds to hang in the pocket.  And the defense is shutting down the opponent and giving the offense the ball back (at least some of the time).

We could have had Rogers in at QB the first two games and we would have sucked.

This is not meant as a defense of Cutler, IMO I agree with yttocs here. Jay is just an average QB.  Not the worst and certainly not the best.  Until we have a more consistent offense and defense, QB is not our biggest issue.