Jordan Love, in his 1st season as an NFL starter......

Fields missed 4 games due to injury.  Some might say that was "just a fluke".  I would point out that it happened on a classic Fields screwup play (he literally held the ball >6 secs on that play) and therefore is not an anomaly.

Regardless, as Ric and others have pointed out, its really really hard to call a pass offense for a QB with his issues.  Getsy for all his shortcomings was the fall guy, let's be honest.  Unless JF has excellent pass pro, he pretty much sucks as a passer.  I have pointed out the details of that ad nauseum so I won't go through every detail again.  When asked to do a quick pass attack, his delivery and release are too slow.  His throws are imprecise too often.  When asked to throw intermediate level, he doesn't read fast enough, misses the middle-of-the-field too often, and sucks at passing with anticipation.  He waits until guys are open, i.e. way too long, and therefore leaves plays on the table plus takes a lot of extra sacks.

So....the Bears had to run the ball a lot.  Because running (which they generally did well at) and chucking an occasional deep shot are the only offensive tactics Fields can run successfully on a consistent basis anyway.

Fields and Love went head-to-head twice and twice Love was the better QB by a large margin. 

It wasn't close.

Honestly, at this point, I have zero confidence that the Bears will make the right choice, whatever that choice will be. I think if we keep Fields, he will continue to struggle and Williams will turn out to be legit. I think if we trade Fields and draft Williams, then Williams will end up sucking and Fields will go on to be a star. It doesn't even matter at this point, the Bears never make the right decision, whatever that decision should be.

The one thing I know 99.9% is that Harrison, unless he breaks a knee, is going to be a phenomenal WR who does not need a better QB than Fields to do what Moore did with Fields.  The two of them will rack 2000+ with Fields or whoever comes after him IMO.