Post by riczaj01 on Dec 13, 2016 5:40:09 GMT -6
"in a black and white world, is yes."
no, no you cannot. The jobs of a 4-3 OLB and a 3-4 OLB are not the same. The jobs of a CB in a man cover and in a zone cover are not the same. The jobs of a 3-4 DE and a 4-3 DE are not the same. You know that, and everyone else knows that but you cannot admit it b/c you know it makes PFF grades pointless. Thanks for playing, end of discussion.
Why would you pay attention to scheme, you are grading him vs other people playing the same scheme. Unlike PFF you aren't grading the entire NFL against eachother, you are grading only players on the Bears. What you are looking at is the ILB stopping the run(his job in a 3-4), unlike PFF who is going to grade Nick K vs a 4-3 ilb's as if they are expected to do the same things.
So he gets +1 for any positive stop he makes, but only 1/2 neg no matter how bad he is? He gave up 8 yards to a TE and he only get -.5 but he gets +1 for an assit on another guys tackle? lol okay biased shown, discussion over.
btw, 1st half, 8 rushes, 2nd half 20 rushes, didn't notice the neg grade for a RB going up the gut and being tackled by a CB for 14 yards.
I can see why you didn't do the 2nd half, Nick name comes up only 2 times, and his blocks seem to be taken by Amos or another CB.
no, no you cannot. The jobs of a 4-3 OLB and a 3-4 OLB are not the same. The jobs of a CB in a man cover and in a zone cover are not the same. The jobs of a 3-4 DE and a 4-3 DE are not the same. You know that, and everyone else knows that but you cannot admit it b/c you know it makes PFF grades pointless. Thanks for playing, end of discussion.
Why would you pay attention to scheme, you are grading him vs other people playing the same scheme. Unlike PFF you aren't grading the entire NFL against eachother, you are grading only players on the Bears. What you are looking at is the ILB stopping the run(his job in a 3-4), unlike PFF who is going to grade Nick K vs a 4-3 ilb's as if they are expected to do the same things.
So he gets +1 for any positive stop he makes, but only 1/2 neg no matter how bad he is? He gave up 8 yards to a TE and he only get -.5 but he gets +1 for an assit on another guys tackle? lol okay biased shown, discussion over.
btw, 1st half, 8 rushes, 2nd half 20 rushes, didn't notice the neg grade for a RB going up the gut and being tackled by a CB for 14 yards.
I can see why you didn't do the 2nd half, Nick name comes up only 2 times, and his blocks seem to be taken by Amos or another CB.
