In the meantime, here are the main takeaways from today:
Cole Kmet is a good fit in Chicago’s new offense, which has allowed him to emerge as an efficient option in the passing game.
--He is not targeted much against man but can be schemed into big plays against man coverage through play action.
--He is much more involved against zone, where he primarily gets used as an effective safety valve underneath.
Robert Tonyan was not very effective in 2022, but there is hope he can improve in 2023 as he is now two years removed from tearing his ACL.
--He was not used much against man, and mostly was an ineffective checkdown catcher when he did get involved. This was a huge change from his performance prior to his knee injury and provides the hope he could be a reliable threat against man coverage if his knee is now fully healed.
--Like Kmet, he is a safe and effective checkdown option against zone coverage.
In the meantime, here are the main takeaways from today:
Cole Kmet is a good fit in Chicago’s new offense, which has allowed him to emerge as an efficient option in the passing game.
--He is not targeted much against man but can be schemed into big plays against man coverage through play action.
--He is much more involved against zone, where he primarily gets used as an effective safety valve underneath.
Robert Tonyan was not very effective in 2022, but there is hope he can improve in 2023 as he is now two years removed from tearing his ACL.
--He was not used much against man, and mostly was an ineffective checkdown catcher when he did get involved. This was a huge change from his performance prior to his knee injury and provides the hope he could be a reliable threat against man coverage if his knee is now fully healed.
--Like Kmet, he is a safe and effective checkdown option against zone coverage.
Maybe the Bears will invest in a TE in next year's draft. It takes awhile to spin up a TE at the NFL level, so might as well get a kid on board in the next draft. I think the Bears have to give Kmet an extension next year too. It won't be cheap.
Lessons Learned Now that we’re 1200 words in on this article, and 2300 on the series overall, let’s look at what we’ve learned about each tight end:
Cole Kmet saw his target volume drop in 2022, but his overall efficiency took a real step forward in a new offense that utilized him more strategically. --This included improving real weaknesses from his first two seasons against man coverage, on 3rd/4th down, and in the red zone. --Kmet is never going to be a high-volume pass catcher who you can build a passing attack around, but he has shown he can be very effective as a secondary weapon. --Stay tuned for a closer look at what type of contract that could merit for Kmet should he sign an early extension prior to the start of the season.
New addition Robert Tonyan had a highly ineffective 2022 season where he wasn’t good for much more than catching dumpoffs in low-leverage situations. --The intrigue comes in looking back at what Tonyan was in 2020 prior to tearing his ACL in 2021. If he can regain that form, or anything close to it, he becomes a legitimate weapon in his own right, and Chicago have two quality starting tight ends with skill sets that complement each other well. --It is important to note, however, that there are no guarantees that happens. Maybe what we saw in 2022 is all that Tonyan has to offer now. If that’s the case, he’s still a perfectly fine backup who can help Chicago’s struggles in the short passing game.
Lessons Learned Now that we’re 1200 words in on this article, and 2300 on the series overall, let’s look at what we’ve learned about each tight end:
Cole Kmet saw his target volume drop in 2022, but his overall efficiency took a real step forward in a new offense that utilized him more strategically. --This included improving real weaknesses from his first two seasons against man coverage, on 3rd/4th down, and in the red zone. --Kmet is never going to be a high-volume pass catcher who you can build a passing attack around, but he has shown he can be very effective as a secondary weapon. --Stay tuned for a closer look at what type of contract that could merit for Kmet should he sign an early extension prior to the start of the season.
New addition Robert Tonyan had a highly ineffective 2022 season where he wasn’t good for much more than catching dumpoffs in low-leverage situations. --The intrigue comes in looking back at what Tonyan was in 2020 prior to tearing his ACL in 2021. If he can regain that form, or anything close to it, he becomes a legitimate weapon in his own right, and Chicago have two quality starting tight ends with skill sets that complement each other well. --It is important to note, however, that there are no guarantees that happens. Maybe what we saw in 2022 is all that Tonyan has to offer now. If that’s the case, he’s still a perfectly fine backup who can help Chicago’s struggles in the short passing game.
An approved Fields will help them succeed as well….
New addition Robert Tonyan had a highly ineffective 2022 season where he wasn’t good for much more than catching dumpoffs in low-leverage situations. --The intrigue comes in looking back at what Tonyan was in 2020 prior to tearing his ACL in 2021. If he can regain that form, or anything close to it, he becomes a legitimate weapon in his own right, and Chicago have two quality starting tight ends with skill sets that complement each other well. --It is important to note, however, that there are no guarantees that happens. Maybe what we saw in 2022 is all that Tonyan has to offer now. If that’s the case, he’s still a perfectly fine backup who can help Chicago’s struggles in the short passing game.
He was a good signing if we recognize it for what it was. His floor is "a perfectly fine backup" and we need one of those. His ceiling could be higher. It takes awhile to completely come back from an ACL. I'll bet this season he is more like pre-injury form. But if not, hey, it's still a good signing.
I keep thinking we need to draft a TE fairly high next year.
"PFF’s Brad Spielberger, who’s the best contract guy out there in NFL media right now, projected Kmet to sign a 4 year deal worth $13.3M per year, with 60% of the money guaranteed. That’s basically Knox’s (TE from Buffalo) deal with higher guarantees, and that seems too small to me, because Kmet has outproduced Knox at the point of signing the extension, is two years younger, and signing on a bigger salary cap. Even taking Knox’s deal and simply extrapolating it to a bigger salary cap would be about $14.8M/year, and Kmet can rightfully claim he should beat that, so I’d say $15M per year is roughly his floor, with $17.5M (the cap-extrapolated version of Dallas Goedert’s contract) his likely ceiling."
"PFF’s Brad Spielberger, who’s the best contract guy out there in NFL media right now, projected Kmet to sign a 4 year deal worth $13.3M per year, with 60% of the money guaranteed. That’s basically Knox’s (TE from Buffalo) deal with higher guarantees, and that seems too small to me, because Kmet has outproduced Knox at the point of signing the extension, is two years younger, and signing on a bigger salary cap. Even taking Knox’s deal and simply extrapolating it to a bigger salary cap would be about $14.8M/year, and Kmet can rightfully claim he should beat that, so I’d say $15M per year is roughly his floor, with $17.5M (the cap-extrapolated version of Dallas Goedert’s contract) his likely ceiling."
+1 And TE's in the draft are going to take at least 2 years to learn the position at the NFL level. And that's not to the ceiling. Kmet really wasn't much until his 3rd season. I think that's more typical than not for that TE position. It's a tough transition.