Post by JABF on Nov 20, 2016 7:48:31 GMT -6
Nov 19, 2016 22:48:13 GMT -6 @soulman said:
I do think we are due to have a change of luck at drafting a QB. Hopefully we will finally draft a better QB. Hopefully the franchise will turn around too. The sports world has proven countless times that struggling franchises can become winners. We've seen that in all major professional sports, most recently in our own city with the Cubs. Nothing wrong with fans having hope. You make a good point about fans turning on a new QB if he struggles initially. You saw that this year after the very 1st NFL game played by Cody Whitehair. Fans calling him a bust. Short arms. Bad snaps. He was garbage. One guy on the old board nicknamed him "Cody Wheelchair" (pissed me off). Fans often are too impatient. With players AND coaches. I like giving people a bit of a chance to prove themselves before I give up on them. And I'm not just talking about sports here.
You can coach 'til you're tearing you hair out but you can't make a right brained thinker into a left brained thinker. Some QBs need more freedom to improvise and make plays while others must be in a strictly run system that fits them because they can't or don't have the creativity to improvise. So it's not about luck it's about being smart and finding the correct fit for the offense your team runs. Skip that step and you have a failure.
With the exception of Mac and maybe Harbaugh to a lesser degree we have failed to do that even in trading for Cutler. He has never been used to his greatest advantage until Gase at least began searching more along that path last year. But with him gone it all disconnected again and we have Fox wanting Cutler to play like Hoyer and he's the antithesis of Hoyer. So again we have a HC who wants a round Cutler to fit onto his square box. It won't work, it never has, and it never will.
So if they keep Fox and run this offense someone better get Fox a more productive version of Hoyer because that's what he wants and what he thinks he can win with. I think he's wrong and in another year we'll find out whose right.
You hit the nail on the head. I am an optimist. It's just the way I am wired.
I will always believe that there is an element of luck (both good and bad) in football. Even if an organization - including ownership, front office, coaches and players - does "right things" there is a luck factor. I believe that is true in the draft also. You can do everything humanly possible to discern who to draft, but there are some things you can't measure or foresee (these are human beings, not machines) so there is a certain percentage of bad luck involved - or good luck.
There are many factors involved. And certainly you need good coaching and the personnel infrastructural in place for a QB to succeed. But I will always believe there is an element of luck involved also.