Chicago Bears 2016 Rookie Class Bye Week Assessment by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr.@wiltfongjr Nov 2, 2016, 8:00pm CDT
The Chicago Bears finished their first half of the 2016 season at a disappointing 2 wins and 6 loses. I don't think many Bears' fans thought it would be so ugly, then again, I don't think many Bears' fans anticipated injuries up and down their roster. Nose tackle, offensive linemen, corners, wide outs, quarterbacks, running backs and linebackers have all missed time this season.
With the bye week coming up, the Bears will have a chance to heal, and hopefully do some self-scouting to get back on the winning track.
I'm taking this mid-season break as an opportunity to delve into the 2016 rookie class of the Chicago Bears in my latest T Formation Conversation podcast (subscribe now on iTunes!). I examine how they've all performed so far and speculate of what the future holds for each of them
Let me know what you guys think about all the 2016 rookies on the Bears right now.
Also be sure to stay tuned for Ken's grades on all of GM Ryan Pace's draft picks and undrafted free agent pick ups through his two years on the job. That article drops later this week!
Nice audio review by WCG's Lester Wilfong Jr. Your comments are welcome.
Leonard Floyd: Below Average (meets expectations)) Cody Whitehair: Above Avg (exceeds expectations) Jonathan Bullard: Below Avg (meets expectations)) Nick Kwiatowski: not enough info (meets expectations) Deon Bush: not enough info (below expectations) Deiondre Hall: not enough info (meets expectations) Jordan Howard: above average (exceeds expectations) DeAndre Houston-Carson: not enough info (below expectations) Daniel Braverman: not enough info (meets expectations)
Others: Ben Braunecker not enough information (meets expectations) Cre'von Leblanc average(exceeds expectations)
The Bears will enjoy some much needed rest and relaxation during their bye in Week 9 after an injury-riddled first eight games resulted in an disappointing 2-6 record.
With half of the season officially in the books, it’s time to take a look at how the Bears’ 2016 rookie class has performed so far. Ryan Pace added nine new faces to the roster via last April’s draft, several of which have started and produced at a high level in the first two months of the season.
Best in Class: Cody Whitehair Grade: A
The Bears’ second-round pick has turned out to be the best of the bunch so far. After a decorated college career at tackle, Whitehair made the move to guard in training camp before an unfortunate injury to Hroniss Grasu created a need at center, which Whitehair has filled at a high level through eight games. Pro Football Focus has the former Kansas State standout graded as the second-best lineman on the Bears this season with an 80.2.
Leonard Floyd Grade: C+
Chicago’s first-round pick was off to a slow start and teetered on receiving a failing grade if it wasn’t for his strong performances against two NFC North rivals in the Packers and Vikings. After tallying just a half-sack through the first six weeks of the season (he missed a couple of games due to injury), Floyd has registered three sacks in the last two games, including a strip-sack of Aaron Rodgers that he recovered for a touchdown in Week 7.
Floyd is starting to flash the pass-rushing upside that made the Bears move up in the first round to get him. He’s a player on the rise and could be in line for a huge second half of the season.
Jonathan Bullard Grade: C
Bullard has played only 141 snaps so far this season and has struggled to make much of an impact. He’s had some moments where he flashed his quick-twitch, penetrating style of play, but he’s struggled to adjust to the power of the NFL in the early part of his rookie season. With Mitch Unrein underwhelming as a starter, Bullard’s reps should increase as the season wears on. He’s had 47 snaps over the last two weeks, the most he’s received in any two-game stretch this year.
Nick Kwiatkoski (Linebacker) Grade: C+
Kwiatkoski should really be an incomplete, but his 79 snaps represent the most of any reserve inside linebacker behind starters Jerrell Freeman and Danny Trevathan. The former West Virginia Mountaineer has been credited with two forced fumbles this season, and he brings a hard-hitting and instinctual style of play to the middle of the defense. He has a bright future and will compete for more snaps in the coming seasons.
Deon Bush Grade: F
The most disappointing rookie from the 2016 draft class has been Bush, the former Miami Hurricane who was picked in the fourth round. He began his first training camp in a competition for starter’s reps, but has experienced a downward slide ever since. Bush has played only one snap on defense through eight games and has been inactive for most of his rookie season so far.
Deiondre’ Hall Grade: B-
Aside from an unfortunate ankle injury that has kept Hall out for the last month, the rookie corner from Northern Iowa has been one of the better cover guys on the field when he’s had the opportunity to play. His year-to-date grade of 73.5 from Pro Football Focus (albeit in only 52 snaps) is the second-best on the team, and even though his playing time has been limited, his talent jumps off the screen. Hall will be a key to the secondary in the second half of the season once he gets back to full health.
Jordan Howard Grade: A-
From a pure value standpoint, Howard might end up being the best of the bunch from the Bears’ 2016 NFL draft. After falling to the fifth round, the former Indiana Hoosier has worked his way up the Bears’ depth chart and is now the unquestioned starter in the backfield. He capped off the first half of the season with over 200 yards of offense in Week 8 against the Vikings, the youngest player in NFL history to accomplish such a feat. He’s going to be the bell cow for the offense moving forward and looks like the next in line of supremely talented and productive Bears’ running backs.
DeAndre Houston-Carson Grade: Incomplete
The sixth-round pick from William & Mary hasn’t played enough to earn a grade yet, registering only eight snaps so far in his rookie season. He was expected to be a depth safety and special teams contributor.
Daniel Braverman Grade: D
After starring in training camp, Braverman failed to make an impact in the preseason and has been relegated to the practice squad through the first two months of the year. Braverman was expected to contribute, at the very least, in the return game this season, but his inability to leapfrog Deonte Thompson on the active roster has been disappointing. With eight games to play, Braverman’s time to make some plays could still be coming.
No doubt that once again our second round pick is the clear winner in this draft so far as Goldman was in the 2015 draft. Maybe we need to start trading down in round one instead of placing so much weight on the upside of top ten picks. Or....maybe we should try winning for a change and boost ourselves out of top ten pick territory.
It seems to me that of late there are usually four or five guys who are solid top ten players and five or six who are far bigger gambles. They rank that high more on the basis of a possibly weaker draft class at that position than they do on their own merits as an NFL ready top dog player.
Statistically more top ten picks disappoint or under perform than those taken with picks 11-20. I suspect the QBs weigh heavily in this as have the OTs more recently. College spread offenses aren't turning out as many NFL ready players at those positions so those guys need to relearn how to play the game NFL style.
Anyway, now that Floyd is being platooned more as a rusher if he's able to continue to produce pressure like he has the past two games he will see his grade rise as well. I can finally envision what he could be like with 10-15lbs more bulk and NFL level strength, some better moves, and an ability to bull rush effectively too.
I think Bullard is in much the same boat. They have him listed at 290lbs but I question whether he's really carrying that much weight at all. He looks more like a 275lb guy not any bigger than McPhee or Houston but without their savvy or strength. He is quick though and getting better against the run.
Kwiatkoski's day is coming. He's too good a hitter and too instinctual to be a backup forever. I like the feeling that by next year we'll have three ILB who can start with no drop off if one of them is hurt. He and Howard may well be the two biggest bargains in this last draft and this is where Pace gets my nod of approval. He's doing far better in the middle rounds than his predecessors so far.
IMHO Bush is Pace's biggest mistake so far. Based on his senior year the kid was a huge reach and can't possibly have ranked higher than Prescott. I still sense Fox's fingerprints all over this pick and that Bush is at best a ST guy who lacks the dedication and football smarts to ever be trusted as a starting Safety. He's a guy who you think can do it but he never will. He may well be one of our worst picks so far and I'm amazed he wasn't cut.
Hall can become Peanut v2.0 eventually. I think he has all the tools to do it and Donatell is a great DB coach. I just wish he wasn't hurt because Bausby is a poor replacement for him. Once he's healthy again I'd like to see him step up and own the #2 CB spot so we can move Fuller to FS where I think he truly belongs.
Howard is stud RB and one of the best value picks in the entire draft. As unlucky as we seem to have been so far with Kevin White I believe Howard can easily make up for it. He's quick and he's powerful and if he can stay healthy bangin' the way he does he's gonna make the RBC approach Fox favors a much smaller committee.
Houston-Carson and Braverman we won't know much about 'til next year but one guy not mentioned I want to see more of these next 8 games is Braunecker.