You'll have to click on the link since this is a photo gallery that can't be copied. It's another mock by a knowledgeable predictor and some may be a bit shocked at the pick. Have some fun with it and then we can discuss it.
You'll have to click on the link since this is a photo gallery that can't be copied. It's another mock by a knowledgeable predictor and some may be a bit shocked at the pick. Have some fun with it and then we can discuss it.
Its a good and realistic mock, unlike some that that are really poorly thought out. In fact, the first 7 picks are precisely the 1st 7 players I expect to be off the board in some order (3 QBs, Barkley, Chubb, Nelson, & Fitz).
But I would be very disappointed in Pace if he passed on Edmunds for Smith at #8 and let San Fran take him the very next pick. I know others may disagree and that's fine. Smith would be a pure ILB in a 3-4 and I see Edmunds as the higher ceiling and more versatile player for Fangio's scheme. Reverse those two picks?---that I could easily see especially since Reuben Foster appears to be in hot water.
You'll have to click on the link since this is a photo gallery that can't be copied. It's another mock by a knowledgeable predictor and some may be a bit shocked at the pick. Have some fun with it and then we can discuss it.
Its a good and realistic mock, unlike some that that are really poorly thought out. In fact, the first 7 picks are precisely the 1st 7 players I expect to be off the board in some order (3 QBs, Barkley, Chubb, Nelson, & Fitz).
But I would be very disappointed in Pace if he passed on Edmunds for Smith at #8 and let San Fran take him the very next pick. I know others may disagree and that's fine. Smith would be a pure ILB in a 3-4 and I see Edmunds as the higher ceiling and more versatile player for Fangio's scheme. Reverse those two picks?---that I could easily see especially since Reuben Foster appears to be in hot water.
Ah.....you did.
I also kind it interesting that they would pass on Edmunds for Smith. Even though Smith might rate slightly ahead of him now Edmunds seems to be the better fit since he could play ILB now while they develop him a bit to see if he can fit at OLB.
But this is what I meant about players rising and falling. Will the Bears or others become more concerned about Edmunds as the draft nears? Will a team overdraft Davenport or Landry? Will the Broncos take Fitz or Ward in place of Allen?
This is the pre-draft rumor period I tend to enjoy most. Team are tossing out smoke screens thicker than a WW II Destroyer and some one is always looking to finagle a trade up or down.
Something noteworthy about both Smith and Edmunds is their age. Smith is 20 and Edmunds is 19. These are young players with lots of growth in them. Edmunds is frequently mentioned when talking about young players and how that provides more of a ceiling for them. Smith also has that room for growth - particularly in terms of strength. Either guy we get is going to have lots of room to grow especially under a talented LB coach like Fangio (who I wonder if he will continue to coach the OLBs this year, like last?).
I don't think it matters a ton who we get of the four most common player picks in drafts (Fitz, Edmunds, Nelson, Smith). It matters most what the coaches see in each of them and how they fit the Bears plans going forward. Any of these guys projects well into the NFL and is a projected play maker.
My one concern is that Pace grabs someone out of this consensus - someone like Landry, who many see as a 2nd round prospect climbing as a result of limited pass rushers in this class. That would be my only concern. If we get Fitz, Nelson, Edmunds or Smith I'll be a happy Bear's fan on Day 1 of the draft. I'll also be happy if we trade down in either the first or second round and recover some picks.
Smith is a bit of surprise if only because the rest of the media sees Nelson or Edmunds but I've felt all along that Smith is a viable pick as well. He's now very similar in size to Danny Trevathan when Trevathan was drafted and to his size now.
It's tough to find much of anything wrong with this pick either. He's been a top athlete, recruit, and player ever since HS and he's added 15-20lbs since leaving Georgia and still ran a 4.5/40 at the combine. At 236lbs he's really no smaller than Trevathan or Freeman both of whom played extremely well in this defense and he may be a bit less of a gamble than Edmunds if we planned to convert him to an OLB. I'd add him to my list and be happy to get him if we decide he's it.
LB ROQUAN SMITH Georgia SEC Combine Results Grade/6.62 40 time/ 4.51 SEC Top Performer
Blue Star = Combine Top Performer
More Draft Video
6'1" Height 32" Arm Length 236LBS. Weight 10" Hands
Overview
One of the top high school recruits in the country (top 30 overall, second-ranked linebacker), Smith stayed in his home state of Georgia to play football after being named the Class AA Defensive Player of the Year by the Atlanta Journal-Sentinel as a senior. He played as a reserve his true freshman season (20 tackles, four for loss) before becoming a defensive leader in 2016. Smith played in all 13 games, starting 10, and leading the Bulldogs with 95 tackles (five for loss, one pass breakup).
Analysis
Strengths: Former high school wideout with elite athletic ability. Speed demon who walks down backs looking to race him to the corner. Fluid and explosive in space. Block-slipper. Praised by his head coach as being a "tremendous leader" who holds himself accountable. Has instincts and football intelligence. Laser-sharp focus to finds the football when sifting through zone reads and jet sweeps. Plays with discipline. Senses when running backs are prepping for screen and fires downhill to stop it. Face-up tackler who sticks his nose in noise. Rare stop-start and change of direction talent. Flips pursuit from one target to the next seamlessly. Gets early bail into coverage against play-fake. Able to mirror and match against the most athletic running backs in coverage. Gets early jumps to join crossing routes and has the speed to carry them across the field. Searches out and squeezes receivers when playing zone.
Weaknesses: Is a little undersized. Has to stay one step ahead of the blocking scheme or he can be engulfed by size. Will need to diagnose and trigger just a hair faster on the next level. Occasionally comes in hot rather than breaking down in space as a tackler. Will need more schooling on hand work when taking on blocks. Needs to do a better job of recognizing oncoming blocker in his periphery. Gets touched up by second level traffic and needs to continue to improve finding more efficient routes to the ball.
Draft Projection: Round 1
Sources Tell Us: "Great player. Really fun to watch because he can get to just about any play on the field and he's only going to get better. You would love to play him inside but he may have to slide to WILL." -- AFC team personnel director
NFL Comparison: Deion Jones (or Ryan Shazier IMHO)
Bottom Line: Smith is an ascending linebacker prospect with elite athletic ability, plus intelligence and an ability to be an effective cover linebacker on passing downs. While he's a little undersized, he does have the quickness and speed to keep himself from being mauled. He was good in 2016, but great in 2017 and projects as a player who hasn't tapped his full potential. Smith has Pro Bowl traits and talent and will come off the board in the first round.
Edmunds is 6-foot-5, 250-pounds at just 19 years old, and it comes on a long, lean frame. He looks unlike the rest of this linebacker group and is already a very good player. He is not, however, in Roquan Smith’s class, and projecting him above Smith requires the assumption that he will put all of his athletic tools together with improved technique and performance at the next level.