"Since the league’s inception in 1920, defenses have had a select few ways to score points. They could recover a fumble and return it for a touchdown. They could intercept a pass and run it in for six points. Or, they could tackle an opponent holding the football in the end zone, resulting in a safety worth two points.
It’s time to take one of those options away from the defense, but weaponize it further for a team’s greater good.
Instead of the traditional two-point safety whenever a player is tackled, fumbles the ball out of bounds or commits a penalty in his own end zone, let’s propose this for the next NFL competition committee meetings:
Instead of the defensive team getting two points, give that team’s offense possession at its opponent’s 20-yard line. If a safety occurs with no time remaining, there will be one untimed down."
But not for the reason you think....but for diversity reasons. His proposed plan:
"1) Head coaches pick eight coaches from their staff—four on offense and four on defense—and have them rotate as play-callers every four games.
2) For the 17th game, the head coach can pick the two coaches they deem as the best play-callers on the staff; one on offense and one on defense. These coaches can also be the full-time play-callers in the playoffs."
"Here is what I propose instead: If a team is trailing by fewer than three points, or tied, it can not attempt a field goal in the final 40 seconds of the game. If the field goal would only tie up the game, then sure, go for it—but it cannot be a go-ahead score. The team in the lead can also still kick a field goal at any point."
But not for the reason you think....but for diversity reasons. His proposed plan:
"1) Head coaches pick eight coaches from their staff—four on offense and four on defense—and have them rotate as play-callers every four games.
2) For the 17th game, the head coach can pick the two coaches they deem as the best play-callers on the staff; one on offense and one on defense. These coaches can also be the full-time play-callers in the playoffs."
Nah-don’t see it. You hire passed on competency. If your HC is that guy, so be it. The HC develops his staff much like developing players.
"Here is what I propose instead: If a team is trailing by fewer than three points, or tied, it can not attempt a field goal in the final 40 seconds of the game. If the field goal would only tie up the game, then sure, go for it—but it cannot be a go-ahead score. The team in the lead can also still kick a field goal at any point."
Takes playing strategically out of the game. If anything, make the FG only worth the points to induce a tie hence leading to overtime…
"Since the league’s inception in 1920, defenses have had a select few ways to score points. They could recover a fumble and return it for a touchdown. They could intercept a pass and run it in for six points. Or, they could tackle an opponent holding the football in the end zone, resulting in a safety worth two points.
It’s time to take one of those options away from the defense, but weaponize it further for a team’s greater good.
Instead of the traditional two-point safety whenever a player is tackled, fumbles the ball out of bounds or commits a penalty in his own end zone, let’s propose this for the next NFL competition committee meetings:
Instead of the defensive team getting two points, give that team’s offense possession at its opponent’s 20-yard line. If a safety occurs with no time remaining, there will be one untimed down."
(I might be talked into this one actually.)
Can’t buy this. Make it worth 3 points and red zone as well.