2 teams get A+ grade for offseason. Bears & Lions.

I will grant you that the QB position is different from any other in that success/failure is very binary.  For a rookie contract QB with the team that drafted him it is either "good enough to pay huge money" or NOT.  

There's no "average starter" or "good depth player" at QB.  

With Fields specifically, there's no doubt the team screwed up his time here.  I said so at the very moment they kept Pace/Nagy which set the whole clown show in motion.  I won't go thru all the details again but they clearly failed to align the incentives and timelines of the GM, HC, and QB. They made similar mistakes with Trubisky and Cutler too.  

Having said all that, Fields did have a decent cast to work with in 2023 and he fell well short of what he needed to do to remain a starter.  The rest of the league confirmed the reality that some Bears fans had trouble accepting -- 2500 yards passing isn't worth much in trade and no one was gonna hand him a starting job.  Those are BACKUP type of numbers.